Without question, the highlight of this 4th of July was the first annual rib-off versus my brother-in-law, B.I.L. B.I.L has significant advantages: a smoker…deep(er) pockets…past success…two kids…a Prada shirt. Undaunted, I charged forward with my Smart&Final card, and guts. Guts, goddammit!
Four racks of baby back ribs. I did not get what I paid for. They smelled funny. (B.I.L., sorry I failed to mention this to you. And your wife.)

The rub: brown sugar, salt, chili powder, and a bunch of other shit I found in our cupboard. I think it was too much. Plus, I made about 1 1/2 cups of rub which I would later find out is enough for, oh, about 12 racks of ribs. Did I accidentally use all 1 1/2 cups on my 4 racks? Yes. Yes I did.




Getting ready to rub some ribs. (Note that I didn’t go there.)

Rubbed, rested and ready for a 12-hour nap in the fridge.



After resting in the fridge, we poured about a half cup of liquid in each pouch (white wine, worcestershire, honey, garlic) and let them braise for about 3 hours in a 250° oven. It would smell very good very fast. Just saying.
Post-bake, we reduced the braising liquid into a glaze, painted the ribs, and broiled it crispy chewy.


The ribs came out fall-off-the-bone tender, but had a funky, totally un-rib-like flavor. It wasn’t right. It was nasty, frankly. I think the combination of bad meat plus too much rub yielded something pretty inedible. They were still suprisingly popular, though. Most satisfying comment: “Damn you, Louie, and your melt-in-your-mouth texture!”

B.I.L’s Ribs
B.I.L.’s smoker is about the most beautiful piece of hardware I have ever seen. It smells like success. Jerk.

Hardwood chips soaking in water. He’s not messing around. Bastard.

The lid comes off and out of the thick, rich smoke emerges super-dark, nearly shellacked ribs. What an ass.




Look at that smoke ring!

Okay, his ribs rocked. Deep, deep smoke flavor, good salt, pork that was actually porky. B.I.L was disappointed with the toothsomeness, but I flavor beats out tenderness every time.

So in the end, they were being nice and voted it a tie. But B.I.L. won fair and square. Not bad for my first time, but I’m looking forward to my comeback come Labor Day. Retribution!